How many years do you spend with the same class or the same teacher in primary school?
October 19, 2025
In the US, we have one teacher per year, and starting in 5th grade, there is a different teacher for each subject, for each year. There are 4 levels for each subject. At least this was true for,me in New England.
24 comments
8
We start in group 1 at 4 years old. Then stay in primary school until we finish group 8 (most kids will be 12 at that point). Then we go to high school/secondary eduction. Which takes either 4, 5 or 6 years (if you don’t have to repeat the year). There we’ll have a different teacher for each subject.
At least when I was a kid, most kids would spend grades 1 to 6 with the same teacher who would teach most subjects, apart from sports or crafts or music which had specialized teachers, then move to a school for grades 7 to 9 where you would be nominated a homeroom teacher but spend a lot of classes with specialized teachers for most subjects.
Tiny local schools for grades 1 and 2 also existed, and kids from those schools would go to a bigger one for grades 3 through 6. I’m under the impression that the network of these 1-2 schools is smaller than it used to.
We spend all of primary school (6 years in my part of Germany) with the same class. We had one teacher who was sort of the main teacher, who we would have for most of our subjects during the first years, and as more and more specialised subjects were introduced we would have different teachers for those. I think during the first two years we had all subjects with the same teacher except maths and P.E. Our main teacher changed in year 3, but I think it was only due to our first teacher retiring.
For years 7-10 we changed school, but still had one class with the same students all the time, but the teacher would usually change for each subject and there were a few subjects where you could choose (e.g. either geography or politics) and then you wouldn’t be with your class for those but with everyone who had chosen geography. For the last 2 years everything was based on which subjects you choose, so you wouldn’t really have one class anymore.
In general we spend all of primary school (4 years) with one teacher. There might be a change due to maternity leave, retirement or other factors that make the teacher unavailable, but the general rule is that the teacher moves years with their class and starts anew with new first grade kids once his class finished primary school. After that it’s different teachers per subject and in general they move from grade to grade with you, even though there are more changes due to bureaucratic necessities (also most high school teachers teach two subjects, so you might have the same teacher for two subjects).
Ireland has eight years of primary school (Junior infants, senior infants, 1st class to 6th class). Generally you stay with the same group of kids all the way up (some schools with multi form entry might mix the classes around from one year to the next). Generally you would have a different teacher each year, but all subjects would b taught by the same class teacher. Some smaller schools have mixed age classes with two year groups in one class. In that case you’d stay with the same teacher for two years, but half the kids in the class would change as the years moved up.
We have one per year (except if the teacher work part time then a sub can be present all year too).
For the class, it depends on the size of the school. In the one I was in, it was only 1 class per year so we were with the same student from age 3 (when school starts here) to grade 5 (“CM2”). In smaller schools it’s one teacher for 2 to 3 grade and in tiny isolated one it’s only one teacher for all grades.
In bigger school you could have 2 or 3 class of each grade and they try to mix the group from a year to another.
It might differ from place to place.
Primary school is for six years (not counting Kindergarten) and in my case, the class itself stayed the same, but changed the teacher and hence the classroom every two years.
For secondary levels I and II it’s completely different.
The same school often have classes for year 1-3 or 1-6, so depending in the school you may have the same class teacher for three or six years. You usually change teacher, and often but not always school, for year 7-9. But in the later years you will have different teachers for different subjects, just that one will be the teacher with main responsibility for your class.
In Wales, my primary school was very, very small so my experience didn’t mirror the norm (I had two year groups sharing both a classroom and a teacher).
In secondary school (starting in the school year where you would turn age 12), every subject had a different teacher, but we were assigned one teacher per subject per year so we would just go to their classroom when we had that lesson timetabled. We did not retain those teachers as we aged up the years. For example:
– in year 7 I might’ve had Maths taught by Professor Plum in classroom B12, English taught by Miss Scarlett in classroom A9, History taught by Mr. Green in classroom C15.
– in year 8 I might’ve had Maths taught by Colonel Mustard in classroom B5, English taught by Mrs. Peacock in classroom A5, History taught by Mrs. White in classroom C12.
And so on and so forth. My school had something like eighty teachers (maybe 4-5 per subject), and ~1500 pupils. It was unusual for you to have the same teacher for the same subject two years in a row.
In my primary school you’re with the same class all throughout (at least for me) we had two classes per year A or B and they were formed based on alphabetical order of the first surname. First half of the alphabet go to A and the second half to B. Those are 6 years, from age 6/7 until 12/13.
The teachers would change each year. In the first years maths and Spanish language was taught by the same teacher and English and science by other. In the later years we had one specific teacher for each subject.
In high school you would change class pretty much every year since the number of students is bigger, also the branch of studies you choose. We had a different teacher for each subject too.
1st to 4th grade in Slovakia.
Primary school lasts 5 years here, and unless the teachers retire or are transferred to another school, they will follow the same class and students for all 5 years.
Usually they’re two to four, not counting the religion teacher and the occasional support teachers, and divide themselves in the various school subject (Italian, English, history, geography, math, music, etc.).
Primary school: every class has its own teacher for a year. Sports and religion usually have separate teachers who teach their subject to multiple classes.
Secondary school: there is a different teacher for each subject. This changes every year. Of course it’s also possible that you get the same teacher for two subjects or for two years in a row.
The same class the whole way up, unless someone was kept back a year (either from our class ot the one above. Both happened at least once.)
The teachers, different every year, but I still managed to have overlap. I had the same teacher for Junior Infants and Second Class, and then a different teacher twice too, this time for First Class and Third Class.
I spent 1-9 in the same school and growing up I thought that was the norm. When we started seventh grade we got students from three other schools that only had 1-6.
One teacher in preschool, one in grade 1-3, one in 4-6.
7-9 different teacher per subject aprox, some teachers had double to say. But same teachers true the years.
Gymnasium (high school/college? we are 16-19yold in gymnasiet) one teacher per subject.
First 4 years one teacher for everything (usually the same teacher whole time), after that different teacher for each subjet (but teachers have 2 subjects specialization so I had the same teacher for social studies and geography for example).
Class is the same all the time.
When I was in Primary School I had the same teacher for most subjects throughout all four years. I had separate teachers for English, Music, and PE. From 5th grade onward it was usually one teacher for each subject though sometimes the same teacher would teach two.
I spent all 4 years (can vary by state) with the same class and the same teacher. You have one “class teacher” and in primary school that teacher will also teach most of your subjects. The stuff I wasn’t taught by her was french and music (and we sometimes had lessons in other subjects in french with the french teacher). PE or swimming specifically is sometimes also done by other teachers, but mine had the necessary training so she could do it herself.
In secondary school you will also mostly stay with your class until grade 10, as grade 11-12/13 (currently depends on the state, but will be 13 when the current 5th graders reach that point) will be university qualifications where you pick your subjects. There is still a “class teacher” in secondary school, but they will be in that position for one or two years and teach one or two subjects and mainly serve administrative purposes.
In German elementary schools, normally, kids stay with the same class for all four years, but get a different teacher after 2nd grade. The reason is they don’t want kids to have the same teacher for four years if they can avoid it. Sometimes, teachers change after a year already, obviously, teachers do sometimes take parental leave or change schools. Elementary school teachers teach almost every subject, only subjects like Physical Education, Arts & Crafts and Religion often have more specialized teachers.
In Austria we have one teacher for 4 years in every school. Things change I think I don’t have kids. But that’s the usual main teacher
Sweden here. I spent the first six grades with the same class. I had one teacher in grade 1-3, another in grade 4-6 and a third in grade 7-9. The first six grades the one teacher basically taught most or all subjects (except for a few), but in grade 7-9 our “main teacher” only taught a few subjects and we had other teachers for the rest. You stayed with your class, though.
Normally 4, then kids are split into Gymasium or Middle school. The middle schoolers gt a main class teacher for another 4 years, the Gymnasium kids get specialised teachers for every subject.
Germany here.
This is a foreign concept to me.
I went to elementary school for 4 years in a village and to Gymnasium for 9 years in two medium sized towns.
The maximum amount of subjects a teacher has taught me was 3 in elementary school and 2 in Gymnasium, but more than 1 was rare.
The maximum amount of years a teacher taught me is 3, usually the teacher for each subject changes after 1-2 years.
Which is logical because when they study, they study 3 subjects.
From the top of my head I had 10 different teachers in elementary school
24 comments
8
We start in group 1 at 4 years old. Then stay in primary school until we finish group 8 (most kids will be 12 at that point). Then we go to high school/secondary eduction. Which takes either 4, 5 or 6 years (if you don’t have to repeat the year). There we’ll have a different teacher for each subject.
At least when I was a kid, most kids would spend grades 1 to 6 with the same teacher who would teach most subjects, apart from sports or crafts or music which had specialized teachers, then move to a school for grades 7 to 9 where you would be nominated a homeroom teacher but spend a lot of classes with specialized teachers for most subjects.
Tiny local schools for grades 1 and 2 also existed, and kids from those schools would go to a bigger one for grades 3 through 6. I’m under the impression that the network of these 1-2 schools is smaller than it used to.
We spend all of primary school (6 years in my part of Germany) with the same class. We had one teacher who was sort of the main teacher, who we would have for most of our subjects during the first years, and as more and more specialised subjects were introduced we would have different teachers for those. I think during the first two years we had all subjects with the same teacher except maths and P.E. Our main teacher changed in year 3, but I think it was only due to our first teacher retiring.
For years 7-10 we changed school, but still had one class with the same students all the time, but the teacher would usually change for each subject and there were a few subjects where you could choose (e.g. either geography or politics) and then you wouldn’t be with your class for those but with everyone who had chosen geography. For the last 2 years everything was based on which subjects you choose, so you wouldn’t really have one class anymore.
In general we spend all of primary school (4 years) with one teacher. There might be a change due to maternity leave, retirement or other factors that make the teacher unavailable, but the general rule is that the teacher moves years with their class and starts anew with new first grade kids once his class finished primary school. After that it’s different teachers per subject and in general they move from grade to grade with you, even though there are more changes due to bureaucratic necessities (also most high school teachers teach two subjects, so you might have the same teacher for two subjects).
Ireland has eight years of primary school (Junior infants, senior infants, 1st class to 6th class). Generally you stay with the same group of kids all the way up (some schools with multi form entry might mix the classes around from one year to the next). Generally you would have a different teacher each year, but all subjects would b taught by the same class teacher. Some smaller schools have mixed age classes with two year groups in one class. In that case you’d stay with the same teacher for two years, but half the kids in the class would change as the years moved up.
We have one per year (except if the teacher work part time then a sub can be present all year too).
For the class, it depends on the size of the school. In the one I was in, it was only 1 class per year so we were with the same student from age 3 (when school starts here) to grade 5 (“CM2”). In smaller schools it’s one teacher for 2 to 3 grade and in tiny isolated one it’s only one teacher for all grades.
In bigger school you could have 2 or 3 class of each grade and they try to mix the group from a year to another.
It might differ from place to place.
Primary school is for six years (not counting Kindergarten) and in my case, the class itself stayed the same, but changed the teacher and hence the classroom every two years.
For secondary levels I and II it’s completely different.
The same school often have classes for year 1-3 or 1-6, so depending in the school you may have the same class teacher for three or six years. You usually change teacher, and often but not always school, for year 7-9. But in the later years you will have different teachers for different subjects, just that one will be the teacher with main responsibility for your class.
In Wales, my primary school was very, very small so my experience didn’t mirror the norm (I had two year groups sharing both a classroom and a teacher).
In secondary school (starting in the school year where you would turn age 12), every subject had a different teacher, but we were assigned one teacher per subject per year so we would just go to their classroom when we had that lesson timetabled. We did not retain those teachers as we aged up the years. For example:
– in year 7 I might’ve had Maths taught by Professor Plum in classroom B12, English taught by Miss Scarlett in classroom A9, History taught by Mr. Green in classroom C15.
– in year 8 I might’ve had Maths taught by Colonel Mustard in classroom B5, English taught by Mrs. Peacock in classroom A5, History taught by Mrs. White in classroom C12.
And so on and so forth. My school had something like eighty teachers (maybe 4-5 per subject), and ~1500 pupils. It was unusual for you to have the same teacher for the same subject two years in a row.
In my primary school you’re with the same class all throughout (at least for me) we had two classes per year A or B and they were formed based on alphabetical order of the first surname. First half of the alphabet go to A and the second half to B. Those are 6 years, from age 6/7 until 12/13.
The teachers would change each year. In the first years maths and Spanish language was taught by the same teacher and English and science by other. In the later years we had one specific teacher for each subject.
In high school you would change class pretty much every year since the number of students is bigger, also the branch of studies you choose. We had a different teacher for each subject too.
1st to 4th grade in Slovakia.
Primary school lasts 5 years here, and unless the teachers retire or are transferred to another school, they will follow the same class and students for all 5 years.
Usually they’re two to four, not counting the religion teacher and the occasional support teachers, and divide themselves in the various school subject (Italian, English, history, geography, math, music, etc.).
Primary school: every class has its own teacher for a year. Sports and religion usually have separate teachers who teach their subject to multiple classes.
Secondary school: there is a different teacher for each subject. This changes every year. Of course it’s also possible that you get the same teacher for two subjects or for two years in a row.
The same class the whole way up, unless someone was kept back a year (either from our class ot the one above. Both happened at least once.)
The teachers, different every year, but I still managed to have overlap. I had the same teacher for Junior Infants and Second Class, and then a different teacher twice too, this time for First Class and Third Class.
I spent 1-9 in the same school and growing up I thought that was the norm. When we started seventh grade we got students from three other schools that only had 1-6.
One teacher in preschool, one in grade 1-3, one in 4-6.
7-9 different teacher per subject aprox, some teachers had double to say. But same teachers true the years.
Gymnasium (high school/college? we are 16-19yold in gymnasiet) one teacher per subject.
First 4 years one teacher for everything (usually the same teacher whole time), after that different teacher for each subjet (but teachers have 2 subjects specialization so I had the same teacher for social studies and geography for example).
Class is the same all the time.
When I was in Primary School I had the same teacher for most subjects throughout all four years. I had separate teachers for English, Music, and PE. From 5th grade onward it was usually one teacher for each subject though sometimes the same teacher would teach two.
I spent all 4 years (can vary by state) with the same class and the same teacher. You have one “class teacher” and in primary school that teacher will also teach most of your subjects. The stuff I wasn’t taught by her was french and music (and we sometimes had lessons in other subjects in french with the french teacher). PE or swimming specifically is sometimes also done by other teachers, but mine had the necessary training so she could do it herself.
In secondary school you will also mostly stay with your class until grade 10, as grade 11-12/13 (currently depends on the state, but will be 13 when the current 5th graders reach that point) will be university qualifications where you pick your subjects. There is still a “class teacher” in secondary school, but they will be in that position for one or two years and teach one or two subjects and mainly serve administrative purposes.
In German elementary schools, normally, kids stay with the same class for all four years, but get a different teacher after 2nd grade. The reason is they don’t want kids to have the same teacher for four years if they can avoid it. Sometimes, teachers change after a year already, obviously, teachers do sometimes take parental leave or change schools. Elementary school teachers teach almost every subject, only subjects like Physical Education, Arts & Crafts and Religion often have more specialized teachers.
In Austria we have one teacher for 4 years in every school. Things change I think I don’t have kids. But that’s the usual main teacher
Sweden here. I spent the first six grades with the same class. I had one teacher in grade 1-3, another in grade 4-6 and a third in grade 7-9. The first six grades the one teacher basically taught most or all subjects (except for a few), but in grade 7-9 our “main teacher” only taught a few subjects and we had other teachers for the rest. You stayed with your class, though.
Normally 4, then kids are split into Gymasium or Middle school. The middle schoolers gt a main class teacher for another 4 years, the Gymnasium kids get specialised teachers for every subject.
Germany here.
This is a foreign concept to me.
I went to elementary school for 4 years in a village and to Gymnasium for 9 years in two medium sized towns.
The maximum amount of subjects a teacher has taught me was 3 in elementary school and 2 in Gymnasium, but more than 1 was rare.
The maximum amount of years a teacher taught me is 3, usually the teacher for each subject changes after 1-2 years.
Which is logical because when they study, they study 3 subjects.
From the top of my head I had 10 different teachers in elementary school